Call for Bushwacker to be blocked

[David WJ Sherlock]

Bushwacker is just a trouble maker. I have called for the moderators to block his account, why not do the same.

[marky 54]

on what basis other than having a differing view?
i dont always agree with his way of thinking but at least he debates evidence and put across the views of the otherside of the arguement.
how else can people debate both sides of the arguement without people like bushwacker?

i'd say ban the ones who just rant CT'er with no evidence in there posts for why they come to those conclusions over bushwacker and others.
i dont agree with them but if they were banned where would the opposite side of the arguement come from?

i have not seen any outright abusive posts other than words like conspiraloon ect, he dosnt often post outside of critics corner and does debate evidnce or even provide it to argue his points.

if im missing something here can you point out what im missing.

[locsen]

if you start banning trouble makers you are going down the tony bliar road of criminalising those who have a different opinion.


IMHO



let him post, if its pish it will be ignored anyway

[Bushwacker]

[ian neal]

The moderators are perfectly willing to listen to requests for another user to be banned by PM. In fact we appreciate users alerting us to other users they consider to be breaking the moderation policy (see suggestions section). But this should be by PM and not on the forum and it should be for clearly breaking the policy.

I rarely visit CC so I don't really have an informed opinion but if bushwacker actually argues the evidence and does so respectfully that places him/her above many others in CC

This thread will now be locked

Thanks