"Jules Naudet's First Plane Shot was Staged"

[gruts]

[gruts]

[Ray Ubinger]

[karlos]

apart from 911 the naudet brothers have not done anything else EVER
so YES IT WAS ALL STAGED
they are part of the problem

i looked all over the web and found no pre 911 stuff
so they are not renowned award winning filmakers
they are stooges

[Mark Gobell]

I did find this:

http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1150227/

http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1150228/

The only other film credit that they have is Hope, Gloves and Redemption from 1999

Everything else is 9/11 related.

[John White]

2 years between projects is not unreasonable, they may not have been world reknowned but it cant be said they had "done nothing before": so that does shoot Stelios down somewhat. Of course, that could be a cover story: and of course, even if it was their very first film, it doenst mean they couldnt have shot the footage they did: none of it proves anything one way or another: its simply adding and substracting factors from what we individually consider credible

[Mark Gobell]

It's just another in a long long list of the incredible events of 9/11.

[karlos]

well we can hardly call them acclaimed filmakers
why would french filmakers who have done virtually zilch before be hired to do a documentary about the new york fire dept?

i am not suggesting anything about the footage here please note
i am merely asking the question as to has anyone checked them out.
Aparantly it says they filed a lawsuit against loose change.
Why would 2 unknown virtual novices be hired ahead of many thousands more experience filmakers? Why french too? to win french support for the attack on Iraq?

oh and where is this documentary?
Or did they just forget it and concentrate on 911 in the end?

[karlos]

[Ray Ubinger]

[karlos]

Exactly.

I am not claiming the footage is fake. I am claiming the Nadet brothers are plants.
they have no track record
and no reason to have been there making the film
it is all a set up
My personal view is by picking french people it was an attempt to get franch to participate in the forthcoming war
instead france broke the fact that 911 was an inside job

the Naudet brothers are part of the propaganda machine and part of the 911 conspiracy.

They need to be investigated and exposed

actually i have just read the link above.
They are being investigated and they are scam artists possibly MOSSAD

[gruts]

[John Gault]

My, my, what a brave group of truthlings we have here.

Have ANY of you performed a frame-by-frame analysis of the Naudet’s DVD before reaching your conclusions?

Easier just to parrot what you read/heard/ been told elsewhere?

The Naudet DVD is nothing more than a staged, scripted and computer-generated collection of lying propaganda created to help sell the Big Lie.

Ray, Les and others have highlighted some serious problems with this “documentary”. I will point out the physically impossible images which prove much of the video was created on a computer.

I challenge anyone who has: 1) a copy of the DVD, 2) a map of Manhattan, 3) a basic understanding of physics and 4) an understanding of the relationship between the position of the sun and the time of day to step up and “show us what you got”.

No games, no doublethink, no groupthink, no appeals to authority; just you, me and the images on the DVD.

Put up or shut up.