Critics posting outside critics corner

[ian neal]

Don't, basically

The occasional post to notify other users of a thread in CC fine, but certain critics are continuously flouting the rules of this forum by regularly posting outside CC.

Enough. Further examples of this will lead to an immediate ban.

[johndoe]

you tell 'em iain! can't allow any dissent or debate here. oh no. that would be a travesty.

you keep them all nice and concentrated so you don't have to deal with them, it's not like doing that will give you a bunch of yes men and no real answers. oh no that wouldn't happen at all.

ian neal the chairman of democracy.

[Ignatz]

Though presumably "Other Controversies" is fine, as it's not 9/11 related?

(p.s. nice nifty bit of work earlier )

[Johnny Pixels]

Yes, can we have confirmation of the "legality" of posting in other controversies? Seeing as the rules specify 9/11 critics, not conspiracy critics.

[Ignatz]

[ian neal]

I've explained why critics corner exists. Take it or leave it.

And FYI no critics cannot post in other controversies.

John Doe having reviewed your posts I consider you a critic so please post only in CC.

If the critics want to CC moderated or structured differently I will listen to suggestions

[Ignatz]

[johndoe]

"John Doe having reviewed your posts I consider you a critic"

that's odd since you said being a critic meant purely someone who did not see the need for a new report into 9/11

care to point out anything where i have said any different?

"If the critics want to CC moderated or structured differently I will listen to suggestions "

i've already given you a suggestion.

[Johnny Pixels]

[Johnny Pixels]

And for comparison:

http://www.hannity.com/forum/showthread.php?t=50819

I started that thread on 21st Jan 2006, it ran until 25th Feb 2007, and may still get more replies. It is the most viewed, and most replied to thread on the religion section of the Sean Hannity forums.

For those of you who don't know, these forums are frequented by right wing Christian fundamentalists, and the thread pretty much questioned the whole basis of their belief, yet they allowed it to continue. There was never an atheists corner that I was shoved into, or a liberals corner, or whatever. The neocons can do it, but the truth movement can't

[Ignatz]

[marky 54]

[marky 54]

the above comment is meant for the thread as a whole, i pressed qoute instead of post reply for some reason, although i was distracted at the time on the phone as well as typing this, doh.

[Ignatz]

[Johnny Pixels]

[ZUCO]

I think it's fair. The purpose of this forum is for like minded people to discuss how best to inform the population about the truth of 9/11. Therefore this must come first. Critic's have no genuine reason for being here other than to cause disruption and call us all nutters so you can say it in Critic's Corner. I don't see the problem.

[Johnny Pixels]

[marky 54]

[marky 54]

[Johnny Pixels]

[Johnny Pixels]

[wickywoowoo]

I've never quite understood why critics would want to waste their time posting on a forum that they rarely, if ever agree with the contents of, BUT, I've also never understood why the 'critics' are banished to one section of the forum alone.

I guess the moral of this post is that I don't understand much.

[Ignatz]

[marky 54]

i dont like restrictions, however the forum has rules and if i want to post here ill stick to them. if i dont like it ill find another forum or start my own, it not like its my job and ive been issued to deal with 9/11 uk truth now is it, therefore the rules are unimportant because i could always move on and have an opinon elsewhere it dosnt restrict my freedom, but i can see paid debunkers having a problem as stuff will be said they cannot smear with bull.

to tackle your second point it was delibrate to assume your thoughts as you do mine, i may as well play along and prove my point right by presuming your thoughts, a tatic you used in your original post and do so in many.

the third point is simple, you dont have to post here. we do however have to live in the world of lies and resrictions to our daily lives and future on a daily bases yet you defend this.

if its so bad just post elsewhere its not like this is the only forum that has imposed restriction on critics to its aim/subject. i feel critics corner is a fine ideal as you can post in relation to any topic that is mentioned elsewhere and have your say and engage in debate without a thread in the general section being spammed by an obsessive with garbage and no evidence and just goes on about how we are all nutters etc etc. if the bcc and simular sites had a simular function i might actually get a message accepted so this freedom of speech thing dosnt seem so bad here to me compared to other major forums. when i complained once on another forum i was simply told my freedom is not restricted as i am not being stopped from posting my opinons elsewhere. sound advise i thought so i pass it on to you.

[Johnny Pixels]

[marky 54]