Should no planers be consigned to critics corner?

[kc]

As no planers continue to pour scorn on the ideas of CD or LIHOP in any sense, I see more and more posts from them containing more factual "debunking" than anything the critics come up with. Is it time to classify them as critics and move their posts accordingly?

[chek]

Well if they walk like ducks ... though actually any association even by way of analogy is being grossly unfair to ducks.

What I would agree with is ruthless pruning of their multiple threads, though without the not very practical full-time attention from the mods, that's not really achievable either.

Within the limitations of this type of message board, I'm not sure there is any easy answer. It's the problem of free speech in a free society in microcosm.

We'll just have to be satisfied with exposing their ideas for the dross they are.

[John White]

I kind of view critics corner as the home of left brain prisoners (anally retentive in freudianism) and truth controversies as the home of right brain prisoners (that will be the anally expulsive, funnily enough): with a few notable exceptions, but thats generalisms for you

I would'nt want to go merging threads and so on particularily, as its better to show what NPT theorists are like when left to develop a natural habitat, though obviously I clear up messes elsewhere on the forum, as there is such a thing as too much fertalizer

I have toyed with the idea of creating a "NPT Theory greatest pwnings" thread, but have found that, on the whole, I can't be bothered. A quick search of relevant members posts delivers all the counter arguments one could require

Mind you, here's a hoopy bit of thinking I came across and added a comment to earlier today, when elsewhere on t'internet: